Auto-renewal of car insurance

Allowing your insurer to auto-renew your car insurance is one of the most common mistakes made by customers who want to save.

Alice Morgan
Alice Morgan
Updated 25 June 2021  | 2 min read

Does car insurance automatically renew?

Unless you tell your car insurance provider otherwise, it’s likely your policy will automatically renew.

It happens when you come to the end of your car insurance deal, usually around 12 months after you take out the policy.

Sometimes your insurer will charge you more for sticking with it, even if nothing’s changed on your policy.

Although it’s less hassle to let your insurance roll over for another year, you could be missing out on savings with another provider.

Key points

  • Don’t let your insurance auto-renew - you could end up paying more than you need to
  • New customers are often offered discounts and deals that don’t apply to existing customers
  • Save on your insurance by shopping around

Is auto-renewal legal?

It’s entirely legal for insurers to auto-renew your car insurance contract but by law, they must tell you:

  • Last year’s price - so you can easily compare it to your new premium
  • To check your cover and to shop around for the best deal - if you’ve renewed four times in a row, they need to encourage you to shop around.

This is all to make sure you’re treated fairly, because it’s in your best interests to see if you can get a better deal elsewhere.

In 2020, almost 7.6 million drivers allowed their car insurance to auto-renew. That means the UK missed out on a collective saving of £2.1 billion.[1]

The real cost of loyalty

According to our research, 27% of drivers assumed they would get a good deal this time around because their provider was the cheapest last year.

Other reasons for sticking with the same provider included concern over the hassle and ease of switching (19%).

However, 22% of drivers stayed put because they paid monthly and didn't want the fuss of rearranging their direct debit.

We also asked drivers about the renewal information they received from providers.

Less than half (49%) said they compare their renewal premium with what they paid the previous year, just over a third check their renewal papers for any changes to the cover, while just 29% thought about the cover they'd needed for the coming year. This could become an issue if you try to make a claim on your windscreen protection for example and find you’re not covered anymore.

Don’t auto-renew – compare quotes now

Get a quote

How to stop your insurance auto-renewing

Make sure you stop your auto-renewal before the policy start date if you think you’ll be paying too much – you can use us to compare prices.

If you’d rather stick with your existing insurer, get in touch and see if you can negotiate a better price. Explain that you’re a loyal customer and see what they can do for you.

If they won’t budge on price, tell them to cancel your auto-renewal.

Just make sure you do it in good time – if you let your policy auto-renew you’re still allowed to cancel, but you’ll probably be charged for the time you’re covered by them and an administration fee - even if you’re still in your cooling off period.

It doesn’t take long to compare prices with us instead, and it could save you money.

Most importantly though, make sure you always have valid insurance in place and the right amount of cover for you.

Compare and save on your car insurance

Start a quote

[1]On 8 February 2021, an online survey of 2,042 randomly selected Great British adults was executed by Maru/Blue. For comparison purposes, a probability sample of this size has an estimated margin of error (which measures sampling variability) of +/- 2.1%. The results have been weighted by age, gender, region and social grade to match the population, according to Census data. This is to ensure the sample is representative of the entire adult population of Great Britain. Discrepancies in or between totals are due to rounding.

Department for Transport’s Vehicle Licensing Statistics for Quarter 4 2020 (published December 2020) report that there were 31.869m cars licenced for use on the roads in Great Britain. 24% of motorists auto-renewed their car insurance policy at the last renewal without checking prices. 24% of 31.869m = 7,648,560.

7,648,560 x GoCompare Car Insurance’s average shop around saving of £277.17 = £2.1bn.